Independent community site, not affiliated with any government.

Fire Island, New York vs Newark, New Jersey

Two towns in different states side by side, from the US Census Bureau records their own pages show. Both are in the New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ Metro Area metro area.

Fire Island, NYSuffolk County

Population 445 (2019-2023 estimate)

Newark, NJEssex County

Population 317,303 (2024 estimate)

Side by sideACS 2019-2023
Fire Island compared with Newark, American Community Survey 2019-2023
MeasureFire IslandNewark
Population445307,188
Median household income$90,179$48,416
Median age48.734.8
Median home value$608,500$337,800
Bachelor’s degree or higher39.0%17.4%
Foreign-born residents14.2%34.9%
Owner-occupied homes77.4%24.1%
Mean commute to work41.7 minutes33.2 minutes

Sources: American Community Survey 5-year data profile 2019–2023, place level, state 36, released December 12, 2024, retrieved November 16, 2026; American Community Survey 5-year data profile 2019–2023, place level, state 34, released December 12, 2024, retrieved November 16, 2026.