Independent community site, not affiliated with any government.
MI

Middle Island, New York

Census designated place in Suffolk County, New York · ZIP 11953

A census-designated place: a statistical area the Census Bureau draws, not a municipality. Local government is Brookhaven Town.

  • Suffolk County
  • Within Brookhaven Town
  • Census data · ACS 2019-2023
  • 1 public schools
  • 11,086 (2019-2023 estimate)Population
  • 4,486Households
  • $89,702Median household income
  • $347,900Median home value
  • 1Public schools
  • 1ZIP codes

About Middle Island

Middle Island is a census designated place in Suffolk County, New York, in the New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ metro area with 11,086 residents (2019-2023 Census estimate). [1][2] Its share of residents born outside the United States is 9.8% (2019-2023), 7 points below Suffolk County’s 16.6% and 13 points below New York’s 22.6% and 4 points below the national 13.9%. Among the 126 towns in Suffolk County with the figure it ranks 89th, and 435th of 749 in New York. [1] Its share of homes that are owner-occupied is 66.7% (2019-2023), 15 points below Suffolk County’s 81.9% and 12 points above New York’s 54.3% and 2 points above the national 65.0%. Among the 158 towns in Suffolk County with the figure it ranks 148th, and 1683rd of 2,141 in New York. [1] Its median age is 43.4 (2019-2023), 1.7 years above Suffolk County’s 41.7 and 3.8 years above New York’s 39.6 and 4.7 years above the national 38.7. Among the 166 towns in Suffolk County with the figure it ranks 104th, and 1137th of 2,145 in New York. [1] Its share of adults with a bachelor’s degree or higher is 31.9% (2019-2023), 8 points below Suffolk County’s 39.9% and 8 points below New York’s 39.6% and 3 points below the national 35.0%. Among the 160 towns in Suffolk County with the figure it ranks 134th, and 919th of 1,940 in New York. [1] Its share of workers who work from home is 6.8% (2019-2023), 4 points below Suffolk County’s 10.7% and 7 points below New York’s 13.3% and 7 points below the national 13.5%. [1] 1 public school lies inside its boundary; it is in congressional district NY-1; its ZIP code is 11953. [1][2][3]

Computed from the records cited, sentence by sentence, in the records’ own periods; not written by the town government and not an opinion.

Town intelligence

Official sources, refreshed yearly
Population, 2000 to 2020+8.7%
9.5k10k10.5k11k2000: 9,70220002010: 10,48320102020: 10,54620209,70210,546
Population of Middle Island at each census
CensusPopulation
20009,702
201010,483
202010,546

As counted at each census, within the boundaries the area had then; the current estimate is in the glance card.

Sources: Census 2000 Summary File 1: total population, place level, state 36, retrieved November 14, 2026; Census 2010 Summary File 1: total population, place level, state 36, retrieved November 14, 2026; Census 2020 Redistricting Data (P.L. 94-171): total population, place level, state 36, released August 12, 2021, retrieved November 14, 2026.

Household income in Middle Island
Under $50k28.9%
$50k to $100k24.4%
$100k to $150k17.5%
$150k to $200k18.7%
$200k and over10.6%

Median household income $89,702 · Share of households by income, American Community Survey 5-year 2019-2023, table S1901.

Source: American Community Survey 5-year subject table S1901 (household income) 2019–2023, place level, state 36, released December 12, 2024, retrieved November 14, 2026.

Housing tenure in Middle Island
Owner occupied
2,993 units
Renter occupied
1,493 units
Vacancy rate
7.6%

Occupied housing units by tenure and the share of all units vacant, American Community Survey 5-year 2019-2023, table DP04.

Source: American Community Survey 5-year data profile 2019–2023, place level, state 36, released December 12, 2024, retrieved November 16, 2026.

Middle Island compared with its county and stateACS 2019-2023
Middle Island compared with its county and state, American Community Survey 2019-2023
MeasureMiddle IslandSuffolk CountyNew York
Population11,0861,525,68019,872,319
Median household income$89,702$128,329$84,578
Median age43.441.739.6
Median home value$347,900$539,500$403,000
Bachelor’s degree or higher31.9%39.9%39.6%
Foreign-born residents9.8%16.6%22.6%
Owner-occupied homes66.7%81.9%54.3%
Mean commute to work31.6 minutes31.7 minutes32.8 minutes

Source: American Community Survey 5-year data profile 2019–2023, place level, state 36, released December 12, 2024, retrieved November 16, 2026.

Not yet on this page: community posts, upcoming events. Join Middle Island to post or add an event, or ask Middle Island a question; a person checks everything before it shows.

Schools

Public schools in Middle Island1
Public schools in Middle Island, NCES directory 2023–2024
SchoolTypeGradesDistrict
LONGWOOD MIDDLE SCHOOLPublic5–6LONGWOOD CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT

Open public schools in the NCES directory for 2023–2024, placed by their listed location; private schools are not in the source. Enrollment and ratings are not shown.

Sources: NCES Common Core of Data, public school directory 2023–2024, retrieved November 14, 2026; NCES EDGE public school geocodes 2024–2025, retrieved November 14, 2026.

Climate

Climate near Middle Island1991-2020 normals

At Mt Sinai, NY, 7 km from Middle Island, the 1991-2020 normals put the average July high at 83.1 °F and the average January low at 26.3 °F, with about 48.5 in of precipitation a year.

Monthly climate normals at Mt Sinai, NY, 1991-2020
MonthAverage highAverage lowPrecipitationSnow
January41 °F26.3 °F3.7 inNot available
February42.9 °F27.8 °F3.2 inNot available
March50 °F32.8 °F4.7 inNot available
April63.7 °F42.8 °F4.4 inNot available
May71.7 °F51.4 °F3.9 inNot available
June78.2 °F61.1 °F3.9 inNot available
July83.1 °F67.5 °F3.9 inNot available
August81.8 °F67 °F4.0 inNot available
September74.7 °F61.3 °F4.3 inNot available
October64.8 °F48.8 °F4.2 inNot available
November56 °F40.3 °F3.7 inNot available
December46.1 °F32.1 °F4.6 inNot available
Year48.5 inNot available

NOAA’s 30-year normals for the nearest station with a full year of temperatures, 7 km from the town’s centre; the town itself may differ.

Source: NOAA NCEI US Climate Normals 1991–2020, monthly, by station (v1.0.1), retrieved November 16, 2026.

Legislative districts

Legislative districts for Middle Island6
Congressional and state legislative districts for Middle Island
ChamberDistrictShare of Middle Island
U.S. House of RepresentativesCongressional District 1 (NY-1)All
State legislature, lower chamberAssembly District 235%
State legislature, lower chamberAssembly District 341%
State legislature, lower chamberAssembly District 424%
State legislature, upper chamberState Senate District 130%
State legislature, upper chamberState Senate District 370%

Boundaries from the Census Bureau’s TIGER/Line district files, matched to Middle Island’s own boundary; a town split between districts lists each with the share of its land inside it. Who holds each seat appears on the People page once the official records are approved.

Sources: Census cartographic boundaries 2025: congressional districts, 119th Congress, retrieved November 14, 2026; Census cartographic boundaries 2025: state legislative districts, upper chamber, state 36, retrieved November 14, 2026; Census cartographic boundaries 2025: state legislative districts, lower chamber, state 36, retrieved November 14, 2026.

Frequently asked about Middle Island

Answered from the records
Which county is Middle Island in?
Middle Island is in Suffolk County, New York.
What is the population of Middle Island?
11,086 residents, by the US Census Bureau’s 2019-2023 estimate.
Is Middle Island a city, a township or a census-designated place?
Middle Island is a census designated place in the Census Bureau’s geography. A census-designated place is a statistical area, not a municipality; local government is Brookhaven Town.
What ZIP codes cover Middle Island?
11953. These are Census ZIP code tabulation areas, which approximate USPS ZIP codes.
Which congressional district is Middle Island in?
Which state legislative districts include Middle Island?
Upper house district 1 and 3; lower house district 2 and 3 and 4.
Which school district serves Middle Island?
The public schools inside its boundary belong to LONGWOOD CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT (NCES directory).
What is the median household income in Middle Island?
$89,702, by the American Community Survey (2019-2023).
What is the median home value in Middle Island?
$347,900, by the American Community Survey (2019-2023).
What is the unemployment rate in Middle Island?
4.4% of the civilian labor force, by the American Community Survey (2019-2023).
How do people in Middle Island get to work?
81.0% of workers drive alone, 1.0% take public transportation and 6.8% work from home, by the American Community Survey (2019-2023).
How many households in Middle Island have broadband?
90.5% of households have a broadband subscription, by the American Community Survey (2019-2023).
What languages are spoken in Middle Island?
11.5% of residents aged five and over speak a language other than English at home, by the American Community Survey (2019-2023).
What does rent cost in Middle Island?
The median gross rent is $1,774 a month; 22.7% of renting households pay under $1,000 and 35.9% pay $2,000 or more, by the American Community Survey (2019-2023).
How old are the homes in Middle Island?
22.4% of homes were built before 1970 and 11.1% since 2000, by the American Community Survey (2019-2023).
What share of homes in Middle Island are single-family?
58.6% of housing units are single-family homes, detached or attached, by the American Community Survey (2019-2023).
What is the climate like in Middle Island?
At Mt Sinai, NY, 7 km from Middle Island, the 1991-2020 normals put the average July high at 83.1 °F and the average January low at 26.3 °F, with about 48.5 in of precipitation a year.

All questions and answers

Where Middle Island ranks

Towns like Middle Island in New York

Similar in population and median household income, by the Census figures on their pages.

Moving to Middle Island

Moving to Middle Island: the figures first
Median gross rent
$1,774 ± $133 (2019-2023)
Median home value
$347,900 ± $36,404 (2019-2023)
Owner-occupied homes
66.7% ± 5.7 points (2019-2023)
Median household income
$89,702 ± $15,614 (2019-2023)
Mean commute to work
31.6 minutes ± 2.4 minutes (2019-2023)
Adults with a bachelor’s degree or higher
31.9% ± 4.1 points (2019-2023)
Residents born outside the United States
9.8% ± 3.3 points (2019-2023)
Speak a language other than English at home
11.5% ± 3.1 points (2019-2023)
Households with broadband
90.5% ± 4.0 points (2019-2023)
Work from home
6.8% ± 4.1 points (2019-2023)
Take public transportation to work
1.0% ± 0.7 points (2019-2023)
Unemployment rate
4.4% ± 2.1 points (2019-2023)
Public schools inside the boundary
1 (NCES directory)
Average high in July
83.1 °F (NOAA normals 1991-2020, nearest station)
Average low in January
26.3 °F (NOAA normals 1991-2020, nearest station)
Precipitation a year
48.5 in (NOAA normals 1991-2020, nearest station)
Legislative districts
6 (Census boundary files)
ZIP codes
11953 (Census ZCTAs)
Metro area
New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ (Census CBSA)
Land area
8.22 sq mi (Census Gazetteer)

Rent by bedroom, climate, the nearest airport and colleges are added as those datasets are loaded; nothing here is estimated.

Sources: American Community Survey 5-year data profile 2019–2023, place level, state 36, released December 12, 2024, retrieved November 16, 2026; NCES Common Core of Data, public school directory 2023–2024, retrieved November 14, 2026; NOAA NCEI US Climate Normals 1991–2020, monthly, by station (v1.0.1), retrieved November 16, 2026; Census 2020 ZCTA relationship file: ZCTAs to places, retrieved November 14, 2026; Census Gazetteer 2025: places, retrieved November 14, 2026.

Where Middle Island is

Map of the boundary of Middle Island, Suffolk County, New York, from the US Census Bureau's cartographic boundary file (2025)
The boundary the Census Bureau draws for Middle Island; streets and places inside it are not shown. A census-designated place: a statistical area the Census Bureau draws, not a municipality. Local government is Brookhaven Town.

Source: Census cartographic boundaries 2025: places, state 36, retrieved November 14, 2026.

Nearby towns

Compare Middle Island with Gordon Heights, Brookhaven Town, Coram, Rocky Point, Ridge.

Across state lines: Newark, NJ, Jersey City, NJ, Paterson, NJ, Lakewood, NJ, Wantage, NJ, Madison, OH (the New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ metro area or a town of the same size).

Other towns in Suffolk County

All towns in Suffolk County